Crowd favorites

Our Bestselling Cookies

Not sure where to start? These are the boxes people come back for — the flavors that blew up on the feed and the sampler that wins over first-timers.

All baked to order with grass-fed butter and organic flour, shipped fresh nationwide.

Questions, answered

What's your most popular cookie?
The Sicilian pistachio and the Sunday Ritual chocolate chip are perennial favorites. The Intro box is the easiest way to try the lineup.
How fresh are the cookies when they arrive?
Every box is baked to order and shipped fresh — never sitting on a shelf.